Okay, Google: "What is the best city electric bike?"
The browser will offer many options with different styles, price ranges, electronic features, etc. How do you choose the best e-bike from this variety? The most reasonable way is to select and compare a few favourite ones. Comparing popular e-bike models and brands is an excellent way to start the research. How else can you be sure you will buy a dependable, budget-friendly city electric bike that is the best on the Canadian and US market right now?
In this comprehensive comparison by EbikeBC, we'll look into two popular e-bikes with good reviews: the ENVO ST50 and the Denago Commute Model 1 Step-Through E-bike.
ENVO ST50 Electric Bike
Weight: 28 KG (61lb)
Motor: 500W/750W 80Nm
Transmission: SHIMANO Altus 9 Speed
System: PAS/thumb throttle, speed sensor
Sensor: Cadence
Battery: 48V/14AH 3200 LG/Panasonic Lithium battery
Price: $2,679 CAD - $2,0009 USD
Quality Score: 85/10
Denago Commute Model 1 Step-Through Electric Bike
Weight: 29 kg (64 lb)
Motor: Shengyi rear hub motor, 48V, 500W, 50 Nm torque rating
Transmission: Microshift 8-speed drivetrain
System: Pedal Assist and Thumb Throttle, Speed Sensor
Sensor: Cadence
Battery: 48V, 13.6Ah, 652.8Wh, Fully-integrated style, LG cells
Price: $2,438 CAD - $1,799 USD
Quality Score: 75.7/100
Your Best City Electric Bike: Comparing Envo ST50 e-bike and Denago Commute Model 1 Step-Through Electric Bike.
Design:
Both the ENVO ST50 e-bike and Denago Commute Model 1 Step-Through electric bikes offer sleek and sporty aesthetics, integrating their batteries seamlessly for a stylish look. Both electric bikes are designed for an upright-sitting riding position and have step-through frames, providing the same ease of use as traditional bikes. Envo ST and the Denago Commute Model 1 also offer Step-Over (high-step) frames, but in this blog, we'll take a closer look only at the low-step frame design.
The ENVO ST50 is made of premium materials - stylish and unisex aluminum alloy frame in Small and Large frame sizes. The e-bike features a contemporary sporty design with a touch of classic commuter electric bike appearance. While stylish, the Denago Commute Model 1 has a battery integrated on top of the downtube with a slightly higher step-through clearance.
The ENVO ST50 electric bike comes in cactus (light green) for small and matte Maroon (dark red) for large. In contrast, the Denago Commute Model 1 e-bike is available in Bone (nude) and Light Blue colour options.
Ergonomics:
The ENVO ST50 e-bike will be a good fit for riders from 4'11" to 6'5", providing two sizes: large and small. Adjustability in stem and saddle height ensures personalized comfort. Similarly, the Denago Commute Model 1 Step-Through electric bike offers Small/Medium and Large/XLarge sizes, suitable for the same height range as the Envo electric bike. Both e-bikes offer some adjustability, too; you can rotate the stem and set up a comfortable angle, the same as with the saddle that you can move on the rails.
Performance:
The performance of both e-bikes is truly remarkable, thanks to their robust motors and pedal-assist systems that excel in daily commuting and leisurely cycling. The ENVO ST50 impresses with a powerful 750W motor generating 80Nm of torque, enabling up to 45km/h speeds. For Canadian e-bike riders, the system is limited to 500W max output with a 32 km/hr maximum speed. It fully complies with Canadian regulations by capping its power output at 500W. The Denago Commute Model 1 consistently delivers 500W of power with 50 Nm of torque. This model also features a cadence sensor and a fast-charging battery, ensuring efficient and enjoyable rides.
Range and Efficiency:
In the range and efficiency category, the ENVO ST50 takes the lead, offering approximately 150 km as a Class 2 e-bike and 100 km as a Class 3 electric bike on a single charge. The Denago Commute Model 1 covers around 72+ kilometres (45 miles). The actual range may vary depending on terrain, rider weight, and riding conditions.
Control and Monitoring:
With the ENVO ST50 electric bike, you will get a premium colour TFT display with advanced monitoring and parameter settings, including a power-on-demand throttle and enhanced pedal-assist technology. ST50 comes with a Smart Display with Bluetooth compatibility, which allows you to connect to an app and use the navigation feature. Furthermore, you can run a diagnosis analysis on your ST50 using the mobile app. The Denago Commute Model 1 has a Digital LCD display with a PIN lock. Using this high-resolution handlebar e-bike display, you can monitor your speed, distance, battery charge, and other data. Set an optional PIN code for additional security.
Component Grade:
Top-notch and high-quality components define both electric bikes. The ENVO ST50 e-bike uses Tektro hydraulic disc brakes HD-E350, a SHIMANO ALTUS 9-speed gear set, and a 29" suspension fork with 80mm travel. The Denago Commute Model 1 relies on hydraulic disc brakes and a Microshift 8-speed drivetrain, which is a lover class than Shimano used for Envo. The rear light on the Denago Commute needs a separate battery, as it is not powered by a bike as on the Envo ST50, which already has integrated back and front lights. The Denago Commute Model 1 ST uses a 2.6'' tire with more rolling resistance than the Envo ST's 27.5″x1.95, with AV butyle tube. Envo ST50 electric bike also offers compatibility with other tire sizes: 27.5''x2.5'', 27.5''x3.00'' (fat tire), and 29''x2.25'' tires.
Braking Performance:
The ENVO ST50 electric bike and the Denago Commute Model 1 prioritize rider safety by incorporating high-quality hydraulic disc brake systems. These systems offer reliable and consistent braking power, providing confidence and control during rides in various conditions.
Weight:
With the ENVO ST50 weighing 28 kg (61 lb) and the Denago Commute Model 1 at 29 kg (64 lb), these e-bikes feature manageable weights that promote maneuverability.
Serviceability and Spare Parts:
These high-quality city electric bikes are designed for easy maintenance, using available and reasonably priced industry-standard components. The user-friendly design of the ENVO ST50 and Denago Commute Model 1 ensures that riders can readily access the necessary parts.
Access to Service Center:
With widespread dealer networks, the ENVO ST50 electric bike offers accessible professional maintenance and support service centers. ENVO is a Canadian-based company that makes accessing components and servicing in Canada easier. ENVO provides a vast network of dealers across North America, headquartered in Burnaby, BC. You can easily find ENVO dealers' locations using this PAGE.
Denago's service network availability is only focused on the US market, with a few stores across the country.
Accessories Included:
Both electric bikes come with standard accessories like rear racks, fenders, and lights. The ENVO ST50 offers additional customization options, including a cargo rack and suspension seat post. You can even install a different tire size to suit your preferences. The Denago Commute Model 1 Step-through already comes with an included suspension seatpost.
Transmission Reliability:
The ST50 features a 9-speed Shimano Altus system, offering versatile gear options. The Denago Commute Model 1 has an 8-speed Microshift system, which provides less flexibility in gear changing and is lower in the class. Both e-bikes rely on geared hub motors, ensuring smooth performance.
Price:
Priced at $2,679 CAD, the ENVO ST50 offers advanced features and higher power output, making it a competitive choice. The Denago Commute Model 1 is priced at $2,438 CAD, offering less power on the bike.
Final Thoughts: The ENVO ST50 Electric Bike and Denago Commute Model 1 Step-Through Electric Bike each present unique strengths. The ENVO ST50 provides exceptional power, extended range, and advanced features at an attractive price point. The Denago Commute Model 1 offers reliable performance and style.
In the dynamic world of city electric bikes, the decision between the ENVO ST50 and Denago Commute Model 1 hinges on various factors, catering to different rider preferences. The ENVO ST50 stands out for those seeking more power and range, while the Denago Commute Model 1 offers a stylish and dependable option. Both e-bikes symbolize the evolution of urban mobility, enriching your daily journey with cutting-edge technology, safety, and style.
